- 1995: New York Newsday’s “Jet of the Year,” as voted on by the paper’s readers.
- 1996: Awarded the Dennis Byrd Award for Most Inspirational Player as voted by his New York Jet teammates.
- 1996: Hofstra University Young Alumni Award in 1996. The award was bestowed to alumni who, within 10 years of graduation, achieved significant accomplishments in professional life.
- 1997: New York Jets “Unsung Hero Award”
- 2000: DIRECTV “NFL Play of the Week” (Week 2 vs. New England for a game winning TD catch in the fourth quarter)
- 2000: DIRECTV “NFL Play of the Week” (Week 4 vs. Tampa Bay for an 18 yard TD catch with :51 seconds left in the game on an HB option from RB Curtis Martin
- 2000: Thurman Munson Award for his outstanding efforts on an off the field and in serving in the community
- 2001: New York Jets Alumni Association’s “Jets Player of the Year”
- 2002: Chrebet’s college jersey was retired in a ceremony at Hofstra University, New York.
- 2005: Awarded the Ed Block Courage Award.